Procurement KPIs are types of performance metrics that can be used specifically to measure, analyse and monitor the performance of procurement and supply activities, both internally (for example, within the function), and externally (for example, across suppliers).
What types of KPIs and performance measures are used in procurement?
Procurement KPIs are metrics that can be used to analyse internal and external procurement and supply activities. They can help organisations manage and optimise efficiencies in areas such as value, time, quality, and cost, helping procurement functions stay on track with their goals.
Here are just some of the procurement KPIs you can measure.
Variance factors: For example, the difference between the price paid for a product or service and the price originally quoted or the number of disputed invoices against total invoices received.
Orders raised: For example, in a manufacturing organisation, the number of items bought by the function from a company ERP system
Supplier lead time: The time from when the supplier receives an order to when the order is shipped.
Ordering efficiency: The number of orders raised, or deliveries received from, a single supplier
On-time-in-full (OTIF): The number of deliveries received from a supplier in line with the delivery date, with no short shipments or quality defects .
SMART KPIs
Effective KPIs should always be SMART, to track, monitor, and manage progress effectively. SMART stands for specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound.
To create SMART KPIs, you will need to focus on your goals and identify how KPIs can be developed to help support them. You will need to consider what you want to measure, how, and over what time period. Effective KPIs should be simple, relevant, and to the point. Overcomplicated KPIs will be difficult to manage. You will also need to define the parameters of success, i.e., what good looks like, and ensure that although this is a stretched target, it is not unrealistic; if it is, it may never be achieved.
Examples of SMART KPIs could be the number of product lines delivered by a supplier in time, on full to the confirmed delivery date, with no defects per day. Success may be defined as 95% of lines confirmed delivered, with no defects (such as quality issues or short shipments). Alternatively, a procurement function may choose to monitor the efficiency of its employees by measuring the number of lines bought against an MRP by each person per day. Success may be defined as 50 lines, per person per day, or 3000 lines across the whole function per month.
Whichever SMART KPIs are selected, you will need to determine the appropriate measurements required to track progress.
Effective KPI Management
When developing KPIs, you will need to consider the best performance metrics to support both the function and the organisation's overarching objectives and strategies. When developing supplier KPIs, it is also important to develop and measure KPIs that focus on the relationship between the buyer and supplier, as these can add significant value.
The process to manage buyer-supplier metrics can be set out as shown covering the five main stages:
Scroll to the right to view the full circle
What are the benefits of measuring procurement efficiencies through KPIs?
SMART, effective internal KPIs can help organisations identify inefficiencies, improve stakeholder collaboration, reduce costs, mitigate risks, and optimise supplier relationships. In addition to measuring suppliers, it is also beneficial for procurement and supply organisations to measure the efficiency of their internal procurement functions. Internal efficiency could be measured by tracking spending levels, or the volume of procurements made.
You could also measure the effectiveness of your processes, for example, your supplier selection and contract award criteria by analysing expected versus actual results to check if the price or quality requirements for a purchase or project were met. If they were not, this could suggest that either process needs to be tweaked to help identify and select more appropriate suppliers, capable of delivering requirements. Measuring suppliers can help aid delivery efficiency, improve quality and provide access to lower prices, creating overall better value products and services and aiding the security of supply.
Why is cost efficiency important?
One of the most important considerations for any procurement and supply function, irrespective of sector or industry, will be the issue of cost. A key purpose for procurement and supply functions is the efficient and responsible allocation of company funding, in order to deliver goods or services that are fit for purpose, capable of fulfilling business needs, and representative of best value.
There are several cost-saving-related KPIs that you can use to monitor cost and price factors to help produce greater outcomes in the areas of cost savings and efficiencies. These include the following:
Return on investment (ROI) Return on investment is a mechanism that measures the profitability of a purchase or project, by assessing the cost outlays against the benefits generated. You could measure the ROI by dividing the annual cost savings generated, by any internal procurement costs. This can help to identify the overall profitability of the function, as well as examining any cost related benefits that have been generated.
Cost reduction This KPI measures any savings achieved through effective cost and procurement management, so may compare factors such as previous cost versus new cost.
Cost avoidance This KPI looks at actions taken to reduce future costs and the savings that don’t appear directly in your organisation’s bottom line.
Spend under management This is the percentage of organisational spend that is managed by the procurement function, calculated by dividing the total approved spend by the Maverik spend.
Monitoring and managing KPIs
Key performance indicators (KPIs) can be used to measure the effectiveness of procurement and supply activities, such as supplier relationships, delivery and quality performance, cost and price metrics and process efficiency. This information can be used to ascertain benchmarking statistics, set targets, drive incentives and manage improvements across many areas. By implementing KPIs, you can monitor, evaluate, and identify areas for improvement.
KPIs can be qualitative or quantitative. Relationship-based KPIs are qualitative measures, whereas traditional KPIs tend to be quantitative measures. KPIs are typically included in supplier contracts to motivate suppliers to achieve and enhance their performance. When developing KPIs for managing suppliers and contracts, the focus should be on critical success factors and key contract elements that align with the organisation’s overall strategy. Effectively using KPIs to manage supplier and contract performance can lead to better communication, improved quality, increased supplier motivation, and early identification of risks.
Forming KPI’s
This model shows how to form KPIs that relate to an organisation’s mission. An organisation’s mission is essentially its purpose: what it exists to do, and is usually supported by a written publicised mission statement, formally acknowledging the purpose of the business. KPIs should be developed to support the goals and objectives of a company, which are created to help achieve the overall mission.
Overall business strategy What is the organisation's mission?
Goals, objectives and critical success What are the long- and short-term objectives related to the mission?
Key business objectives What goals must be achieved to meet the objectives?
Conditions of the contract and key performance indicators What can be measured to evaluate whether the objectives are met?